This striking post and beam construction sits on serene 1.8 acres overlooking Gardiners Creek and Sylvester Manor. With incredible privacy and ample room for a pool and accessory structures, the property is perfect for indoor/outdoor lifestyle and entertaining with a generous open floor plan and multiple decks. Soaring cathedral ceilings and countless oversized windows create a home filled with natural light. Two fireplaces, radiant heat throughout the main living space, three en-suite bedrooms, and a large loft. This waterfront beauty is ready for its next owner to put their stamp on it with a material palate ideally suited for a designer's eye. There are no like-kind alternatives to this unique Shelter Island opportunity.